The educational landscape often witnesses a dubious strategy employed by elementary principals known as a “staff shake up” to address the issue of ineffective teachers within the upper elementary grades, where state standardized tests play a pivotal role. Elementary teachers teach multiple subjects. They must master them all in addition to the classroom environment. This questionable approach involves relocating these struggling educators to what is perceived as ‘easier’ grades, assuming this maneuver will miraculously resolve the challenges these teachers faced in their previous classrooms. Beneath the surface, this method poses several significant problems that demand thoughtful consideration.

First, the notion of an ‘easy’ grade is a fallacy. Every grade level presents unique challenges, and categorizing them hierarchically as easier or more difficult is not only oversimplifying but also undermines teachers’ hard work and dedication in every grade.

The lower grades, often considered foundational, play a crucial role in shaping a child’s perception and love for learning. The Atlantic article “The Collateral Damage of Testing Pressure,” highlights a study that reveals “being assigned a teacher who transitioned from a higher to a lower grade resulted in reduced academic achievement, persisting through at least the third grade.” Research also shows that students who cannot read proficiently by fourth grade are at an increased risk of not graduating from high school.

Moreover, the fallacy of a “staff shake up” becomes evident when considering the inevitable repercussions in the teacher’s subsequent classroom.

If teachers struggled to manage a class of fourth graders, it is unreasonable to assume that kindergarten students will pose fewer challenges. The transition to a different grade requires mastering new content and demands improvement in areas of weakness, such as developing students’ foundational literacy skills.

Without targeted professional development or instructional coaching, this approach sets both the teacher and their students up for failure. Skills essential for effective classroom management, lesson plan development, and lesson execution are universally applicable and should not be considered grade-specific.

Beyond the individual teacher’s struggle, the practice of shuffling teachers around can disrupt the cohesive culture within a school.

Teacher teams often develop strong bonds, and when a less effective teacher is moved to a lower grade, a more effective counterpart may find themselves relocated to an upper grade. This unsettling dynamic can breed resentment among school staff, with the awareness that additional support will be necessary to uplift the struggling colleague. In an environment fraught with time constraints and pressure and a teacher shortage, frequent team reconfigurations make establishing and sustaining a robust school culture challenging.

Principals should reconsider this superficial solution. Rather than relocating struggling teachers to ‘easier’ grades, a more practical approach should involve addressing the root causes of ineffectiveness through providing targeted support, such as lesson plan assistance, lesson modeling, and classroom management skills.

By adopting comprehensive strategies instead of quick fixes, school administrators can uphold the value of effective teaching across all grades and foster a more stable and positive school culture. Most importantly, this ultimately benefits students by putting them on the path to high school graduation.

Indy Kids Winning Inc exists to empower people to make informed education decisions by covering local education issues and providing education resources. Please consider donating to support our work. Your contribution allows us to continue the fight for excellent education for all children.